MoneyGram vs. Ria
Find out which international money transfer service comes out ahead in our comparison of fees, exchange rates and speed.
MoneyGram is a giant in the international money transfer industry, but younger online services like Ria offer competitive rates that can help you save money. We compare fees, exchange rates and transfer speed between MoneyGram and Ria to find out which one comes out ahead.
Which offers lower fees?
MoneyGram
MoneyGram’s fees vary depending on the destination country, transfer amount, payment method and receiving method. Most online transfers cost just $4.99. But if you opt to pay in cash at an agent location in Canada, the fee is usually around $10.00.
Ria
Money transfer fees with Ria also vary based on the destination country, transfer amount, payment method and receiving amount. It’s generally cheaper to pay by debit and send to a bank account than it is to pay by credit and send funds for cash pickup.
Fee amounts typically start around $3 but can go as high as $65 for transfers at the maximum amount ($2,999). Some types of transfers come with zero fees.
Winner: RiaRia’s minimum transfer fee is lower than MoneyGram. The fact that Ria’s maximum fee is higher than MoneyGram’s makes sense given that Ria lets you send more online. Plus, Ria regularly offers zero fees for some transfers, putting it ahead in our comparison.
Which offers better exchange rates?
The midmarket rate is the “true” exchange rate between 2 currencies, or the real value of one currency when exchanged for another currency. The exchange rate you get from money transfer services like Ria and MoneyGram is the midmarket rate minus a small fee worth a percentage of the midmarket rate. This fee is sometimes referred to as a markup on the exchange rate.
A lower exchange rate means more of your money is pocketed by the transfer service and your recipient gets less money. A higher exchange rate means the transfer service pockets less of your money and more goes to your recipient.
MoneyGram
We found that MoneyGram’s exchange rates are often anywhere from just under 1% to 4% less than the midmarket rate, depending on the destination country. For perspective, a 2-3% margin on the exchange rate means you could lose hundreds of dollars on transfers of $10,000 or more.
Here’s how MoneyGram’s exchange rate markup could work if you’re sending CAD to euros (EUR):
- If the midmarket rate is 1 CAD = 0.7297 EUR
- MoneyGram’s exchange rate might be 1 CAD = 0.7113 EUR (2.52% markup)
Ria
Ria takes a substantially smaller margin than MoneyGram, typically between 1% and 3% or more.
Here’s how Ria’s exchange rate markup could work if you’re sending CAD to euros (EUR):
- If the mid-market rate is 1 CAD = 0.7297 EUR
- Ria’s exchange rate might be 1 CAD = 0.7068 EUR (3.14% markup)
Winner: TieWe found that the exchange rate margin deducted by Ria and MoneyGram is similar, although the exact rate you get from either could differ depending on the type of transfer.
Which is faster?
MoneyGram
The amount of time it takes to send funds through MoneyGram depends largely on the receiving method. Transfers for cash pickup are usually available within minutes of sending funds. Funds deposited into bank accounts are usually available within several hours.
Ria
Ria’s transfer speed depends on the way you pay. When you use your credit or debit card, transfers typically arrive within 15 minutes. Transfers funded from your bank account can take up to 4 business days.
Winner: MoneyGramBoth services offer transfers that can be completed within minutes. However, unlike MoneyGram, some transfers through Ria may take up to 4 business days, giving MoneyGram the winning edge.
MoneyGram vs. Ria: Sending $500 to the Philippines
Here’s how fees, exchange rates and transfer speeds break down if you send $500 from Canada to the Philippines through MoneyGram and Ria. In this example, we assume funds are sent to a bank account, payment is made by debit and the fee is paid on top of the sending amount (not deducted from it). This information is current as of March 26, 2022.
| MoneyGram | Ria | |
|---|---|---|
| Transfer fee | $4.99 | $5 |
| Exchange rate | 1 CAD = 41.3979 PHP | 1 CAD = 40.8666 PHP |
| Transfer speed | Within hours | Within minutes |
| Total received | 20,698.95 PHP | 20,433.30 PHP |
In this case, MoneyGram and Ria charge basically the same transfer fee, but MoneyGram offers a stronger exchange rate, resulting in your recipient getting more money.
It’s important to check all the details of your transfer. Lower fees might not mean your recipient gets more money. Similarly, a stronger exchange rate might not mean every other features of a transfer service is also advantageous.
| MoneyGram | Ria | |
|---|---|---|
| Availability | 200+ countries | Approx. 160 countries |
| Fees | Starts around $4.99 | Starts around $3 ($0 fee for some transfers) |
| Exchange rates | Typically from just under 1% to 4% | Typically between 1% and 3% |
| Speed | Minutes to hours | 15 minutes up to 4 business days |
| Transfer limits |
|
|
| Payment methods |
|
|
| Receiving methods |
|
|
| How it works |
|
|
| Read our review | Read our review |
Compare international money transfer services
Our table below lets you compare services you can use to send money abroad. Compare fees, exchange rates and discounts from different money transfer services, and when you have made your choice, click Go to site.
{"niche":"CAFMT"}
1 - 8 of 8
Bottom line
Both MoneyGram and Ria offer competitive money transfer services. MoneyGram transfers may sometimes be faster, but Ria might offer lower fees for some types of transfers. Before sending an international money transfer, carefully compare your options to find the best service for your needs.
More resources on Finder
More guides on Finder
-
Alternatives to TorFX
Looking for alternatives to TorFX for sending money abroad? Check out these reputable money transfer services.
-
How to pay off an overseas debt
Paying off an overseas debt with an international money transfer can lead to huge savings on fees and interest.
-
What is an international money order?
An international money order may not be the best option for sending money overseas. Learn more about money orders in Canada, and find out about other ways to transfer funds abroad.
-
How to receive a wire transfer
Learn how to receive money through a wire transfer in three ways: through a bank, in-store provider or online money transfer specialist.
-
Tax guidelines and regulations for sending large money transfers to the US
Sending a large sum of money to the United States? Find out what laws and documentation your recipient should know about to avoid tax trouble.
-
10 apps like Venmo in Canada
We compare 10 Venmo alternatives to help you find the mobile payment app that suits you.
-
4 Wise alternatives in Canada
Looking for a money transfer service like Wise? Check out these four Wise alternatives.
-
How to track a wire transfer
Most transfer services provide a tracking number to make wire transfer tracking easy.
-
Keep your money safe from money transfer scams
Learn the red flags that signal an online scammer and ways to protect yourself from becoming a victim.
-
How long does an international wire transfer take?
Ever wondered how long it takes for an international wire transfer to arrive in your recipient’s bank account? Find out here.