Finder makes money from featured partners, but editorial opinions are our own.
Advertiser disclosure
Compare car insurance companies
Choose from our A-Z list of 165+ car insurance companies, reviewed by insurance experts.
Finder’s insurance team spent thousands of hours analyzing over 165 car insurance companies to help you narrow down your options. Rely on our unbiased reviews to cut out days of research about each company’s coverage, discounts, free or optional perks and customer reviews.
165+
companies reviewed
companies reviewed
50+
factors compared
factors compared
1,050+
hours of research
hours of research
The 10 largest car insurance companies
These top 10 car insurance companies make up nearly 75% of the personal car insurance market. Taking up such a huge part of the market shows that most drivers trust these companies for their car insurance. Dive in to our reviews of the largest auto insurers to see what the hype is about.
List of car insurance company reviews
Choose the letter from our alphabetized list that corresponds with the name of the company you’re interested in, such as S for State Farm. Then, choose the company name to read our review.
B
E
G
O
R
Compare the largest auto insurers side by side
See how the top companies compare against each other, based on their market share, financial strength and customer service ratings. What these ratings mean:
- AM Best financial strength — Tell whether an insurer has the finances to pay for your car insurance claims.
- Better Business Bureau (BBB) rating — Get an idea of how the company interacts with customers. The BBB rating is based on publicly available information, company complaints and the BBB’s opinion.
- Finder star rating — Our Finder rating scores companies in several areas, including coverage, benefits, financial strength and customer ratings from J.D. Power, the BBB, Trustpilot and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
- Market share — Market share is based on the 2021 National Association of Insurance Commissioners market share report, showing how much business one company gets compared to another.
| Car insurance company | Market share | Finder star rating | AM Best financial strength | BBB rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Farm | 16% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A+ |
| Geico | 13.5% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A+ |
| Progressive | 13% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
| Allstate | 9% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
| USAA | 6% | 4 of 5 stars | A++ | A |
| Liberty Mutual | 5% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A+ |
| Farmers | 4% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A- |
| Nationwide | 2% | 4 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
| American Family | 2% | 4 of 5 stars | A | A |
| Travelers | 2% | 4.5 of 5 stars | A+ | A+ |
Compare the best car insurance companies
Alphabetical list of auto insurance companies
The big brands like Geico and Progressive can offer great perks, prices and availability across states. However, smaller local companies like Arbella or Bear River may offer better customer service or unique perks for your area, career or car.
Compare the full list of companies that offer car insurance coverage directly to any driver:
- 21st Century
- AAA
- Acuity
- AIPSO
- Alfa
- Allianz
- Allied
- Allstate
- American Family
- American Farmers & Ranchers Group
- American National
- Connect (formerly Ameriprise)
- Amica
- Arbella
- Archer Daniels Midland Group
- Auto-Owners
- Automobile Club MI Group
- Bear River Mutual
- Bristol West
- Buckeye Insurance Group
- California Capital
- California Casualty
- Cameron
- Celina Insurance
- Central
- Chubb
- Church Pension Fund Group
- Cincinnati
- Civil Service Employee Group
- Clearcover
- CNA Insurance Group
- Colorado Farm Bureau
- Columbia Insurance Group
- Concord Group Insurance
- Country Financial
- Countrywide
- CSAA Insurance Group
- Cumberland Group
- Cure
- Dairyland
- Direct Auto
- Donegal Insurance Group
- Electric Auto
- Elephant
- EMC
- Encompass
- Erie
- Farm Bureau
- Farmers
- Farmers Mutual Insurance of Nebraska
- Florida Farm Bureau
- Foremost
- Frankenmuth
- Freeway
- Gabi
- Gainsco
- Geico
- Georgia Farm Bureau
- Germania Insurance Group
- Grange
- Grange Mutual Casualty Group
- Gray Insurance Group
- Grinnell Mutual
- Hanover
- Harleysville
- Hastings Mutual
- Hochheim Prairie Group
- Horace Mann Group
- Idaho Farm Bureau
- IMT Insurance
- Indiana Farm Bureau Group
- Indiana Farmers Mutual
- Infinity
- Insco Insurance Services Group
- InsureMyTesla
- Island Insurance Co Group
- Kemper
- Kemper Specialty
- Kentucky Farm Bureau
- Leon Hix Group
- Liberty Mutual
- Lockhart Co Group
- Loya Group
- Main Street Amer Group
- MAPFRE
- Meadowbrook Insurance Group
- Meemic
- Merchants Insurance Group
- Mercury
- MetLife
- Metromile
- Michigan Farm Bureau
- Michigan Farm Bureau Group
- Mile Auto
- Mississippi Farm Bureau
- Missouri Farm Bureau Insurance
- MMG Insurance
- Motion Auto
- Motorists Mutual Insurance Company
- Mountain States Insurance Co Group
- Mutual Benefit Group
- Mutual Of Enumclaw
- National General
- National General Group
- Nationwide
- NC Farm Bureau
- NC Farm Bureau
- New Jersey Manufacturers
- Nodak Mutual Insurance Company
- Norfolk Dedham Group
- North Star Mutual
- NYCM
- Ocean Harbor Group
- Ohio Mutual Insurance Group
- Oklahoma Farm Bureau
- Oregon Mutual
- Pact
- Partners Mutual
- Patriot Insurance Company
- Pekin Insurance
- Pemco
- Penn National
- Pioneer State Mutual
- Plymouth Rock
- Preferred Mutual
- Progressive
- Pure
- Quincy Mutual
- Rockford Mutual
- Rockingham Group
- Root
- SafeAuto
- Safeco
- Safety
- Serenity
- Shelter
- Southern Farm Bureau Casualty
- Starr Group
- State Auto
- State Farm
- Tennessee Farm Bureau
- Texas Farm Bureau
- The General
- The Hanover Insurance Group
- The Hartford
- Titan
- Travelers
- Umialik Insurance Company
- Union Mutual of Vermont
- United
- USAA
- Utica National Insurance Group
- Vermont Mutual
- Virginia Farm Bureau
- WAAIP
- Wawanesa
- Wayne & Washington Mutual Group
- West Bend Mutual
- Western National
- Western Reserve
- Western Reserve Group
- Westfield
- Wolverine Mutual
More resources on Finder
More guides on Finder
-
Loans for Immigrants, Nonresidents and Visa Holders
It is possible for non US citizens or resident aliens to get a personal loan, including a mortgage, in the US. Here’s how.
-
5 Apps Like OneBlinc
Top picks for apps like OneBlinc with higher loan amounts, lower fees or other features.
-
OneBlinc Review: Cash Advances With Monthly Subscription
A review of OneBlinc’s cash advance app, the pros and cons plus what customer reviews and complaints have to say.
-
How to Use Options on Robinhood to Hedge Risk Amid Uncertain Times
Learn how to use Robinhood’s commission-free options trading platform to maximize your investment strategy despite market volatility.
-
Bitcoin to Break the $100,000 Mark for the First Time Ever
Fifteen years since its creation and after years of dramatic rises and falls, bitcoin has finally hit six figures, a feat most thought impossible even a few years ago.
-
MoneyMutual Review: Legit But Not Best Fast Cash Option
Looking for quick funds? Discover if MoneyMutual’s network can meet your emergency needs.
-
WithU Loans: Fast, Expensive, Bad Reviews
A review of WithU Loans, a tribal lender that charges triple-digit APRs and has a pattern of complaints with the Better Business Bureau.
-
BMG Money Review: Good Option But Limited Availability
Need quick cash? See how BMG Money helps employees handle emergencies without a credit check.
-
Guaranteed Approval Loans for Bad Credit: Where to Apply?
Legit lenders don’t offer guaranteed approval loans, but some options come pretty close if you can meet the lenient requirements to qualify.
-
Personal Loans for First Timers with No Credit History
How to get first-time personal loans with no credit history, ways to improve your odds of qualifying and alternative loan options.
Ask a question