Compare KeyBank products: Checking, savings and CDs

Our verdict

KeyBank is a traditional bank offering a suite of personal deposit accounts, loans, investment options and business accounts. It has a large ATM network and over 1,000 branches, which is impressive for a mid-size bank. However, it doesn’t offer much incentive to sign up, as its rates for savings accounts are low compared to the best-of-the-best and are likely to come with a monthly service fee. Its CDs have decent rates but high opening deposit requirements, and rates vary by location and balance. On top of that, you must live in one of the 16 states it services to open an account, which are primarily located in the Eastern US.

Best for: Those near the East Coast in need of a full-service, traditional bank.

Who is KeyBank best for?

KeyBank is best for those on the East Coast looking for a full-service bank. KeyBank offers all the typical products and services that traditional banks offer, such as checking, saving, money market accounts, certificates of deposit, loans and more. And if you prefer in-person banking, KeyBank has a large ATM network and branches spread across the East Coast.

KeyBank offers extra perks if you have multiple accounts, making it best for those in need of multiple accounts. You could earn relationship discounts, higher rates on saving options and get overdraft protection if you link a checking account with a savings or credit account.

How KeyBank stacks up

KeyBank is an FDIC-insured bank, offering many traditional deposit accounts, loans, credit cards and business accounts. For only being in 16 states, it has a large ATM network of 40,000 and over 1,000 branches, which is on the higher end for banks of its size.

Alongside the large network of branches and ATMs, KeyBank also offers a 24-hour automated phone service. It also has a long window for real-person support, offering customer support phone service on weekdays from 7:00 a.m. to midnight ET and weekdays from 8:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. ET. Not many small banks offer customer support that late in the day.

Where it shines

KeyBank has a lot going for it and could be great for those in its service area.

• Variety of accounts. There are three personal checking accounts and a variety of savings account options, which include money market accounts and CDs.
• Support options. KeyBank customers get access to a large free ATM network and many options for customer support, including phone support and in-person support, thanks to its branches.
• Savings roundups. The bank offers a feature called EasyUp. With a KeyBank checking and savings account, each time you make a purchase with your debit card a set amount ($0.10 and $5) is transferred to a savings account or another company to pay off debt.
• Relationship rates. KeyBank also offers relationship rates for having select KeyBank checking accounts and meeting transaction requirements. Get higher interest rates on checking and savings accounts, better cashback rewards on select products or better rates on loans.

Where it falls short

KeyBank’s biggest downfall is its limited availability.

• Just 16 states. If you’re not in one of the 16 states that KeyBank has roots in, you’re out of luck, as you must be in one of those states to qualify for an account.
• Monthly fees and deposits. KeyBank also doesn’t have the best checking accounts we’ve seen, as most require an opening deposit and a monthly fee.
• High CD deposits. Its CDs have strong APYs, especially on its bonus rates, but they require high opening deposits of at least $2,500.
• Low savings APY. KeyBank’s savings accounts are also subpar, offering very low rates of around 0.01%, which also vary by location. This is much lower than the national average for savings accounts, which is currently 0.43%.⁽¹⁾

KeyBank’s checking accounts

KeyBank has three checking accounts to choose from: Key Smart Checking, Key Select Checking and KeyBank Hassle-Free Account.

Key Smart Checking

The Key Smart Checking account is a popular and affordable option. It has no monthly maintenance fees, a low $10 opening deposit requirement and checkwriting privileges — but no free checks.

There’s also free overdraft protection available if you link a savings or credit account. And thanks to its Key Coverage Zone feature, if you overdraft by less than $20 in one day, you won’t get hit with any overdraft fees.

Key Select Checking

This is KeyBank’s only interest-bearing checking account, offering a variable, compounding rate — but rates vary by zip code, and there’s no range advertised.

The Key Select Checking account isn’t free, requiring a $25 monthly fee that you can waive when you meet at least one of these requirements:

• Receive direct deposits of at least $5,000 each statement period
• Are a KeyWork program member and have at least $3,000 in cumulative direct deposits each statement period
• Have a combined balance of at least $15,000 across all your KeyBank accounts

There’s a $50 minimum opening deposit, and you get $6 in ATM reimbursements and overdraft protection when you link the account to a savings or credit account. Key Select also offers free check ordering, but customizations come with a fee.

One of the better perks is the $100 annual cash bonus, which you can earn year after year with an active account. To qualify, you must set up direct deposits and deposit at least $60,000 over a 12-month-long evaluation period, and at least one deposit must be made within the last 60 days of the evaluation period.

KeyBank Hassle-Free Account

This checking account is rather barebones, with no monthly maintenance fees and a $10 opening deposit.

Unlike the other KeyBank checking accounts, the Hassle-Free account doesn’t come with overdraft protection services, no option for relationship discounts on other KeyBank products and no checkwriting privileges.

KeyBank savings accounts

KeyBank has one traditional savings account and a kids savings account:

• Key Active Saver Account. There’s a $10 opening deposit and a $4 monthly maintenance fee, which you can waive if you have a KeyBank checking account. Its savings rate compounds daily and varies by zip code. However, most locations offer a low 0.01% APY.
• Key4Kids Savings account. Designed for kids under 18, this account has no monthly maintenance fees, requires a $10 opening deposit and can be linked to other accounts for overdraft protection. Interest is compounded daily, but rates aren’t advertised. Parents must visit a branch and sign up on their child’s behalf to enroll and view rates, and the account custodian must be a KeyBank deposit account holder or credit customer.

KeyBank money market savings accounts

KeyBank offers one money market account, called Key Select Money Market Savings®. There’s a $20 monthly maintenance fee and a high minimum opening deposit of $5,000. You can waive the $20 monthly fee by maintaining a balance of at least $25,000 or by having a relationship package with a qualifying KeyBank checking account.

You’ll get unlimited checkwriting, and this account can be linked to a KeyBank checking account for overdraft protection. Another big perk is you’ll get an unlimited number of withdrawals and transfers.

The interest rates are tiered, and interest is compounded daily. However, rates vary based on your relationship to the bank, your minimum balance, and your location. KeyBank doesn’t advertise rates for all balances, so head to a branch to get more information or talk to a representative.

Money market rates

KeyBank rates may vary depending on location. The Annual Percentage Yields (APYs) mentioned are for the ZIP code 10001 in New York as of February 1, 2024.

KeyBank CDs

KeyBank also offers certificates of deposit (CDs), and rates vary by CD, location, term and balance. All of KeyBank’s CDs are available for automatic renewal.

• Short-term CDs. Requires a $2,500 minimum deposit, and terms range from seven days up to six months. Rates by location, but all terms and balances show us an APY of 0.05%.
• Tiered Long-Term CDs. Requires a $2,500 opening deposit, with terms ranging from six months to 10 years. Rates vary by location, but APYs tend to range from 3.75% to 4.74% APY.
• High Yield Jumbo CDs. Requires a high $100,000 opening deposit with terms ranging from seven days to 10 years. Rates largely depend on your term, balance and location — but approximate rates are between 0.50% to 4.74% APY or as high as 5.00% APY for relationship rates.

Business bank accounts

KeyBank also offers a variety of business accounts, all of which can be linked to other KeyBank accounts for overdraft protection.

• KeyBank Basic Business Checking. The most basic option available for a low waivable $5 monthly service fee, offering up to 200 transactions per month and requires a $25 opening deposit.
• KeyBank Business Interest Checking. The only interest-bearing option, and the rate is variable with a low 0.01% APY. This account has a $15 waivable monthly service fee and a $25 opening deposit. You’ll get up to 100 transactions per month and unlimited checkwriting.
• Key Business Reward Checking. The highest transaction allowance with up to 500 transactions per month and unlimited ACH and bill pay transactions. You can receive unlimited domestic wire transfers for free and get three free outgoing wire transfers per month. There’s a waivable $25 monthly service fee and a $25 opening deposit. This account also offers discounts on other KeyBank products, such as the KeyBank Small Business MasterCard rewards credit card.

Other KeyBank products

Aside from deposit accounts, KeyBank offers a multitude of other products and services to consider:

• HSA account. Save for healthcare expenses with this tax-advantaged account with rates ranging from 0.1% to 0.2%.
• Mortgages. Homebuyers can choose from conventional, FHA, Fannie Mae, VA, Jumbo loans and more.
• Variety of loans. Offers a suite of loans, including business, student, personal, auto loans and lines of credit.
• Credit cards. KeyBank offers a variety of credit cards, including business and personal reward credit cards.
• Investments. Invest in IRAs, annuities, mutual funds, college savings plans and more.
• Insurance. Protect your loved ones with life and long-term care insurance through KeyBank.

Compare Keybank with leading bank accounts

Narrow down top bank accounts by fees, APYs, opening deposits and more. Select Compare on up to four providers to see their features side by side.

1 - 5 of 20

Product USFSA-CHK	Finder Score	Fee	Minimum deposit to open	Annual Percentage Yield (APY)	Offer
SoFi Checking and Savings	Finder score 9 Excellent	$0 per month	$0	Up to 4.00%	Get up to $300 cash bonus with qualifying direct deposit. Terms apply. This offer is available until December 31, 2024.	Go to siteView details Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Upgrade Rewards Checking Plus	Finder score 8.6 Great	$0 per month	$0	N/A		Go to siteView details Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Bank of America Advantage SafeBalance Banking®	Finder score 9 Excellent	$4.95 per month (can be waived)	$25	N/A	$300 Bank of America Advantage Banking offer: See offer page for more details. Bank of America, N.A. Member FDIC.	Go to siteView details Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Axos ONE	Finder score 8.4 Great	$0 per month	$0	4.86% on balances of $0+ 1.00% on balances of $0+ 0.51% on balances of $0+		Go to siteView details Compare	loading Fetching your data...
Step Black Card	Finder score 8.6 Great	From $0 per month	$0	4.00% on balances of $0 to $1,000,000		Go to siteView details Compare	loading Fetching your data...

loading

Prev

1 2 3 4

Next

Customer service experience

In terms of customer reviews, KeyBank does pretty well when compared to top banks and credit unions. While there are a number of complaints and some poor customer reviews, they have significantly less than we normally see. KeyBank is also accredited with the Better Business Bureau, holding an outstanding A+ rating with the organization.

The bank doesn’t do too well on Trustpilot, which isn’t uncommon for banks. The majority of reviews are typical grievances we see, such as issues with locked accounts, and a few mention poor customer service. But with over 1,000 KeyBank branches, your experience is likely to vary.

KeyBank has been in business for nearly 100 years, and its record is rather clean. However, in 2022, it was reported that homeowners who had mortgages with KeyBank experienced a data breach that leaked names, addresses and their Social Security number, as reported by AP News. KeyBank reported that its systems and operations were unaffected by the data breach, and it notified all individuals impacted but did not state how many account holders were affected.

To make sure you get accurate and helpful information, this guide has been edited by Holly Jennings as part of our fact-checking process.

Written by

Bethany Hickey

Editor, Banking

Bethany Hickey is the banking editor and personal finance expert at Finder, specializing in banking, lending, insurance, and crypto. Bethany’s expertise in personal finance has garnered recognition from esteemed media outlets, such as Nasdaq, MSN, Yahoo Finance, GOBankingRates, SuperMoney, AOL and Newsweek. Her articles offer practical financial strategies to Americans, empowering them to make decisions that meet their financial goals. Her past work includes articles on generational spending and saving habits, lending, budgeting and managing debt. Before joining Finder, she was a content manager where she wrote hundreds of articles and news pieces on auto financing and credit repair for CarsDirect, Auto Credit Express and The Car Connection, among others. Bethany holds a BA in English from the University of Michigan-Flint, and was poetry editor for the university’s Qua Literary and Fine Arts Magazine. See full bio

Bethany's expertise

Bethany has written 446 Finder guides across topics including:

• Personal finance
• Banking
• Auto loans
• Insurance
• Cryptocurrency and NFTs